Johnny Depp's attempted return to studio leading-man status opened at the top of the North American box office this weekend, but not by the margin Paramount Pictures was hoping for. "Ebenezer," Ti West's gothic retelling of "A Christmas Carol", earned an estimated $19 million from 3,535 theaters in its opening weekend, enough to beat holdovers "The Cat in the Hat" and "Godzilla Minus Zero" to the No. 1 spot but short of the $20 million to $25 million range that trackers had projected heading into the release.
A Costly Bet on a Familiar Story
The film, which casts Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge opposite a supporting ensemble that reportedly includes Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit along with Daisy Ridley, Sam Claflin, Ian McKellen and Andrea Riseborough, carries a reported production budget near $38 million and a marketing spend in the region of $50 million, according to box-office tracking reported by TheWrap. That math means Paramount needs the film to hold well into December — and ideally overseas, where it opened in a similar range — to turn a profit on Depp's first wide studio release since his 2022 defamation trial against ex-wife Amber Heard.
Depp, whose "Pirates of the Caribbean" and "Alice in Wonderland" films helped generate more than $4 billion worldwide at his commercial peak in the late 2000s, has spent much of the past eight years working on smaller independent and European productions after being dropped from the "Fantastic Beasts" franchise. "Ebenezer" is the first time since then that a major studio has put its full marketing weight behind a Depp vehicle, and the opening numbers suggest audiences remain cautious rather than enthusiastic about his comeback — even as the film itself found a more receptive audience among critics.
Critics Split, but Many Praise Depp
Paramount held traditional reviews under embargo until after the opening weekend, but the studio allowed attendees at early screenings to post brief reactions online, and those were notably more positive than skeptics expected. Critics Choice Association member Clarence Moye called the film "a pleasant surprise," adding that director Ti West "brings a lovely gothic visual style which helps freshen an otherwise standard take" on Dickens' 182-year-old novella.
#Ebenezer is a pleasant surprise. Ti West brings a lovely gothic visual style which helps freshen an otherwise standard take.
Clarence Moye, Critics Choice Association
Not every reaction was as kind. Other early viewers described the film as hitting "incredibly well worn territory" with "nothing new to say," while calling Depp's performance itself a highlight — "a pretty standard adaptation," one wrote, "with the heart of Dickens' classic still intact." Social-media commentary skewed toward Depp specifically: one reviewer wrote that he is "a fiendish delight as Scrooge," while another argued the role proves he remains "one of the greatest actors of all time." A smaller number of reactions were far harsher, with at least one review sparing only the production design and musical score from criticism. Full critical reviews, released after the embargo lifted alongside the box-office numbers, will likely sharpen that divide over the coming week.
For West, a horror filmmaker best known for the "X" trilogy he completed at A24, "Ebenezer" marks his first studio release and his biggest budget by a wide margin — a test of whether his signature atmosphere translates to a mainstream holiday property built around a 63-year-old movie star trying to prove he can still open a film.
A Crowded Holiday Calendar Ahead
"Ebenezer" now has to hold its audience against a dense run of new releases. Three other films — "Ghost Soldier," "How to Rob a Bank" and the already-running Hindi epic "Ramayana: Rise of a Legend" — all occupied the weekend's top seven, and the second "Hunger Games" prequel arrives Nov. 20, followed by the usual wave of Thanksgiving-weekend family titles. Paramount's hope is that word of mouth around Depp's performance, rather than the familiar plot, carries the film through the holiday corridor the way studios have long used "A Christmas Carol" adaptations to do.
Whether that happens will say as much about Depp's drawing power five years after the Heard trial as it does about the film itself. Depp has another studio-backed project, the Lionsgate thriller "Day Drinker" opposite Penélope Cruz, still awaiting release — a far clearer signal of where his career stands than a single Scrooge-shaped weekend.